In recent times, a surge in state and local salary transparency laws has triggered employee discontent as workers discover disparities between their current pay and the salary ranges advertised for similar positions. States like California, Colorado, and New York have spearheaded these laws to combat gender pay gaps and other forms of pay discrimination by empowering job seekers with comprehensive compensation information during the hiring process.
The Power of Salary Transparency
Employment law attorneys emphasize that salary transparency significantly influences job applicants’ decisions on which positions to apply for and where. Simultaneously, it equips existing employees with the means to evaluate the fairness of their compensation, potentially exposing companies to legal action for pay discrimination if not adequately addressed.
Want to know if you’re earning what you deserve? Find out with LawCrossing’s salary surveys.
Challenges in Implementing Salary Ranges
As companies increasingly disclose pay ranges in job listings, some have presented wide-ranging figures, making it challenging for job seekers and existing employees to assess fair compensation. Amy Leschke-Kahle, a VP at ADP Inc., notes that finding the right balance is crucial to avoid tensions and confusion. Employers are grappling with navigating this delicate situation, as comprehensive ranges may discourage applicants and unsettle current staff.
The Spread of Salary Transparency Laws
Beyond California, Colorado, and New York, Washington state has implemented a pay transparency measure, with Hawaii and Illinois set to follow suit. Massachusetts is on the verge of passing a similar bill, while Washington, D.C., is contemplating a comprehensive pay equity proposal encompassing transparency in job ads.
Nationwide Compliance and Remote Work
Major companies with significant operations in California and New York are adopting a nationwide compliance approach, addressing the nuances of each jurisdiction’s laws. This trend is accentuated by the rise of remote work, prompting a uniform organizational approach to ensure compliance and attract top talent.
Navigating State-Specific Regulations
Companies like Canam Steel Corp. are facing the challenge of adhering to diverse state and local pay transparency laws. Ron Peppe, Canam’s EVP overseeing HR and legal matters, underscores the practical difficulties in keeping up with different state rules while maintaining a national job search.
Mitigating Pay Discrimination Risks
Legal experts recommend businesses conduct pay scale evaluations, make necessary adjustments, and identify legitimate business reasons for differing pay amounts to avoid potential liability for pay discrimination. This often involves aligning job descriptions, titles, and pay ranges with employees’ actual roles and responsibilities.
Bonus Transparency: The Next Frontier
While the broader goal of ensuring equitable pay will take time for many companies, the transparency laws are nudging them in the right direction. Looking ahead, there’s a growing emphasis on adding pay ranges for bonuses, representing the next phase in the broader movement for salary transparency. Seher Khawaja, a senior attorney for economic empowerment, suggests that job postings should provide specificity regarding any additional forms of compensation, including bonuses.